teqo-backup/.impeccable/critique/2026-07-19T21-47-04Z__src-app-campaign-campanha-login.md

target	total_score	p0_count	p1_count	timestamp	slug
/campanha/login	26	0	2	2026-07-19T21-47-04Z	src-app-campaign-campanha-login

Critique: /campanha/login

Method: dual-agent (A: 8a8b1ae0-9a8a-45f7-907f-54afcdf62db8 · B: 3899acad-4f36-4817-91d6-4135d72d2e96)

Design Health Score

#	Heuristic	Score	Key Issue
1	Visibility of System Status	3	Pending state clear; no other status chrome
2	Match System / Real World	3	PT-BR + e-mail/celular fit; megaphone mark generic
3	User Control and Freedom	2	Only “Esqueceu a senha?”; no exit to public site
4	Consistency and Standards	2	h1 left vs centered muted copy; leading clash
5	Error Prevention	2	required + inputMode help; dual identifier still easy to mistype
6	Recognition Rather Than Recall	3	Labels/placeholder clear
7	Flexibility and Efficiency	3	E-mail or phone + adaptive inputMode
8	Aesthetic and Minimalist Design	2	Header rhythm/alignment + always-on help prose
9	Error Recovery	3	FieldError + leadership recovery hint
10	Help and Documentation	3	Help exists; always-visible first-access competes
Total		26/40	Acceptable

Anti-Patterns Verdict

LLM: Low–moderate slop. Not purple-SaaS; stock shadcn auth shell. Dual muted blurbs feel like copy padding. Typesetting bugs read unfinished.

Detector CLI: exit 0, 0 source findings on login + CampaignAuthPageShell.

Runtime (Playwright inject): flat-type-hierarchy (body; sizes 14/16/20px); nested-cards on CardHeader — likely false positive (shadcn Card > CardHeader).

Overall Impression

Competent Field Desk palette discipline, phone-first form craft — undermined by a campaign-theme h1 { text-align: left } leak and article-style p { leading-7 } on auth copy. Biggest opportunity: fix header typesetting; do not add split-screen public posts.

What's Working

1. Phone-first: min-h-11, enterKeyHint, identifierInputMode
2. Red as signal ≤10%
3. Auth-error recovery hint for liderança phone-only accounts

Priority Issues

P1 — Title misaligned with subtitle

Campaign [data-theme='campaign'] h1 { text-align: left } overrides CardHeader text-center. Title glyph start ~28px left of centered subtitle. Fix: Scope left-align to app chrome, or text-center on auth heading. Command: /impeccable typeset or /impeccable layout

P1 — Subtitle vertical rhythm inverted

CardHeader gap-1 (4px) between title and description; orphan <p> inherits base leading-7 (28px) while CardDescription stays ~20px. Title glued to howto; second muted block breathes like article body. Fix: One muted block with explicit leading-snug; bump title→desc gap; never bare <p> under campaign theme without leading override. Command: /impeccable layout + /impeccable typeset

P2 — Split-screen + public publications: recommend No

Login is ops gate (noindex); posts are public register. Phone users get scroll soup. Motivation ≠ news feed on unlock. Soft maybe: one quiet purpose line under mark — not a publication panel. Command: /impeccable shape only if product insists on panel (internal voice, not posts)

P2 — Generic Megaphone mark

Not Solla / Field Desk identity. Command: /impeccable polish (reuse campaign-logo)

P3 — Always-on first-access paragraph

Progressive disclosure for returning users. Command: /impeccable distill or /impeccable clarify

Persona Red Flags

Casey: Misalignment reads broken; two gray blurbs delay thumb-to-input; split-screen would be fatal. Jordan: Copy helps; visual hierarchy undercuts trust; no public-site escape. Lia: Input path strong; header bugs tax one-handed use; keep error recovery; reject post panel. Sam: Muted contrast scrapes AA (~4.83:1); labels/ARIA look solid.

Minor Observations

• CardHeader grid-rows assumes 2 rows; third orphan <p> is API misuse
• Desktop narrow column is correct for this task
• Placeholder dual-format is heavy

Questions to Consider

1. If the desk is the product, why does the door still look like every shadcn login?
2. Is “inspiring” one quiet line under the mark — or only after auth?
3. Would merging the two muted sentences fix more trust than any split-screen?
4. Who unlocks at 7am in a núcleo — why would they want a publication?
5. Why does auth inherit dashboard h1 left-align rules?